October 8, 2024
ISSUE |
RUSSIAN STANCE |
UKRAINIAN STANCE |
|
1 |
When operation or aggression began, and by whom |
Russia began its defensive military operation against Ukrainian aggression on February 24, 2022 |
Ukraine began its military aggression initially against Donbass on April 14, 2014 and on February 17, 2022; and against Russia in September 2022 |
2 |
Use of weapons against civilians |
Russia has no intention to use weapons against civilians |
Ukraine intentionally uses weapons against civilians |
3 |
Use of chemical weapons (adherence to Chemical Weapons Convention) |
Russia never used chemical weapons |
Ukraine used chemical weapons more than 400 times and violated CWC |
4 |
Use of biological weapons (adherence to Biological Weapons Convention) |
Russia never used biological (bacteriological) and toxic weapons |
Ukraine used biological (bacteriological) weapons and violated BWC |
5 |
Use of cluster munitions |
Russia never used cluster munitions |
Ukraine uses cluster munitions |
6 |
Use of depleted uranium |
Russia never used munitions with depleted uranium (DU) |
Ukraine constantly uses shells with DU in artillery and tank shells |
7 |
Attack on nuclear power plants |
Russia never attacked Ukrainian nuclear power plants (NPP), and has no desire to resort to such actions |
Ukraine attacked two Russian NPP: Zaporozhskaya NPP more than 100 times and Kurskaya NPP 4 times |
8 |
Source of weapons it uses |
Russia produces weapons by itself; it relies on its national defense industrial complex. Russia is against foreign arms deliveries to Ukraine |
Ukraine relies on NATO and non-NATO military industrial complex; it gets weapons from nearly 50 countries. Ukraine demands more lethal arms |
9 |
Treatment of prisoners of war |
Russia treats Ukrainian POW in accordance with Geneva Conventions on POW |
Ukraine violates Geneva Conventions on POW; it has tortured and beaten Russian POW many times |
10 |
Efforts to end aggression |
Russia wishes to end Ukrainian aggression and prepared a draft peace treaty with Ukraine (2022) |
Ukraine has no desire to end its aggression; it blocked the initialed draft treaty with Russia (2022) |
11 |
Major aims |
Major Russian aims in its Special Military Operation: demilitarization and denazification of Ukraine |
Major Ukrainian aims in its aggression: to eliminate population in five territories that joined Russia, and to inflict to it “strategic defeat” |
12 |
Ukrainian membership in NATO |
Russia is against any kind of Ukrainian membership in NATO |
Ukraine is in favor of its full-fledged admission into NATO as soon as possible |
13 |
De-escalation or intensification of conflict |
Russia is in favor of de-escalation of the conflict with Ukraine |
Ukraine is in favor of intensification of the conflict with Russia |
14 |
Deployment of NATO troops in Ukraine |
Russia is against deployment of NATO troops in Ukraine |
Ukraine is in favor of deployment of NATO troops in Ukraine |
15 |
Delivery of dual capable aircraft (DCA) F-16 to Ukraine |
Russia is against delivery of DCA aircraft F-16 to Ukraine |
Ukraine demands to deliver more than 120 DCA aircraft F-16 to its Air Forces. Several such aircraft have already arrived |
16 |
Getting and using long-range NATO missiles deep into Russian territory by Ukraine |
Russia is against getting and using long-range NATO missiles deep into Russian territory by Ukraine. Russia made its updated nuclear strategy much tougher to prevent this |
Ukraine insists on getting and using long-range NATO missiles deep into Russian territory. Ukraine neglected the fact that Russia toughened its updated nuclear strategy to prevent this |
Written by Vladimir P. Kozin